Chances missed in a short-termist budget
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2025/nov/27/chances-missed-in-a-short-termist-budget
Chances missed in a short-termist budget
Despite Wednesday’s budget, massive public spending will still be needed to revive the UK economy, writes Colin Hines. Thu 27 Nov 2025 17.52 GMT
Rachel Reeves’s budget of jam today, increase tax bills nearer the election seems to have appeased the bond markets and backbenchers for a while. Your editorial, however, is correct to say that, over the longer term, the economic revival that so many people and businesses crave will only come when the government spends on the scale required (The Guardian view on Labour’s budget: real gains for children and struggling families are a welcome shift, 26 November).
In the Green New Deal Group’s recent report – A Popular Budget – we outlined how, in the run-up to the next election, the government’s survival will depend on funding a massive programme of social and environmental jobs and infrastructure. This requires the government and the other non-shrink-the-state parties to show the courage to demand that elected politicians take back control of the reins of the economy to achieve this transformation. This will mean reversing the independence of the Bank of England and rejecting the dictates of the Office for Budget Responsibility and the bond markets for more austerity.
Our dependence on the latter could have been dramatically reduced had Rachel Reeves’s budget redirected the tens of billions saved by UK residents every year in Isas, premium bonds and pensions into such a social and green transition.
Finally, the jobs programme that could benefit every constituency and would require a range of skills is one which would dramatically increase energy efficiency and decarbonise the country’s 30m homes. This would have the added advantage of helping tackle the job threats from AI. The Nobel prize winner Geoffrey Hinton recently observed that AI will find it hard to excel at physical manipulation, “so a good bet would be to be a plumber”.
Colin Hines
Convener, Green New Deal Group